Admin comments
“Jannings as the lad's father, and Innkeeper of the “Black Whale,” has occasion to produce almost every one of the wide range of emotions he controls. Rough, bullying and brutal at times, he plays a good-natured and clumsy fellow, afraid to reveal his true feelings save at rare moments. A remarkable character study imbued with real life, the climaxes without obtrusive preparations and free of inappropriate sentimentality. Those who feared for Jannings' future may be sure that he still has his place in the front row. “
Variety, 3/20/1934.
For comparison, I present the 1932 French version with the master of French cinema, Remu, in the leading role. It is very interesting to compare the acting style in French and German cinema. The French is much more expressive, lots of gesticulation. The German is more reserved, more like Soviet/Russian.
Also, I present two American versions made in 1938 and 1961. This is typical Hollywood.